privatedutyaides.com · Care Decision Guide
Assisted Living vs. Nursing Home
Connecticut families face a bewildering choice when a parent can no longer live safely alone. Assisted living averages $8,955/month in CT; nursing homes start around $15,000/month (CareScout 2024 CT data). About 60% of assisted living residents eventually transition to a skilled nursing facility (AHCA/NCAL). Most families consider only those two options — and miss the third that is often most appropriate.
The conversation often starts the same way. A parent falls. Or the neighbors mention they haven’t seen her pick up her mail. Or a son in Fairfield County gets a call from his mother in Westport at 2 a.m. — she isn’t sure where she is.
The family begins researching. They find two categories: assisted living and nursing homes. They tour a facility. They are quoted a number that is larger than their mortgage. And they ask: is there another way?
There is. But first, it is worth understanding what those two options actually provide — and for whom they were designed.
At a glance
What’s the difference between assisted living and nursing home care?
Feature comparison — Connecticut licensed care options, 2024
| Feature | Assisted Living |
Nursing Home |
Private Duty Aide |
|---|
✓ = included or available · — = not provided
What are the real tradeoffs between AL and a nursing home?
The costs, the outcomes, and the option most families miss.
Monthly cost — Connecticut, 2024
Sources: Genworth Cost of Care Survey 2024; privatedutyaides.com
Five-year planning
What do Connecticut families actually spend on AL vs NH?
Private-pay only. Based on 2024 Genworth CT median rates and PDA published rates.
PDA costs: $360/day (8hr @ $45/hr avg) × 260 days = $93,600/yr · 4hr shift = $46,800/yr. NH/AL annualized from CT avg rates. Sources: CareScout 2024, A Place for Mom 2025.
Decision guide
Which is right for your parent: AL, NH, or home care?
Use this framework before touring any facility or signing any contract.
There is no universally right answer. Families with parents who require round-the-clock skilled nursing have no alternative. But the majority of Connecticut families making this decision are not in that situation — they are making it because they feel they have run out of options at home.
“The decision is rarely medical. It’s logistical. And logistics can be solved.”
— Private Duty Aides, client consultation notesA Private Duty Aide does not replace a nursing home for someone who needs one. But for the vast majority of seniors who simply need reliable daily help — with medications, mobility, meals, and a known face — it is often the most humane, most cost-effective, and most reversible path available.
Not sure which path is right?
Private Duty Aides offers free consultations for Connecticut families navigating care decisions. We’ll help you assess the level of need, understand your options, and avoid committing to the wrong one.
Book a free consultation